libhfill is hosted by Hepforge, IPPP Durham

missing logoA histogramming library for Monte Carlo programs


Perturbative QCD description of jet data from LHC Run-I and Tevatron Run-II (arXiv:1407.7031)

S. Carrazza and J. Pires

figure pdf-icon.png Download the full pdf.

Table of Contents
Section 1: Summary
Section 2: CMS 2011 7 TeV
Subsection 2.1: All channels
Subsubsection 2.1.1: Ratio all channels
Subsubsection 2.1.2: K-Factors full prediction
Subsection 2.2: Gluon channel
Subsubsection 2.2.1: Ratio gluon channel
Subsubsection 2.2.2: K-Factors gluon channel
Section 3: ATLAS 7 TeV jets
Subsection 3.1: All channels
Subsubsection 3.1.1: Ratio all channels
Subsubsection 3.1.2: K-Factors full prediction
Subsection 3.2: Gluon channel
Subsubsection 3.2.1: Ratio gluon channel
Subsubsection 3.2.2: K-Factors gluon channel
Section 4: ATLAS 2.76 TeV jets
Subsection 4.1: All channels
Subsubsection 4.1.1: Ratio all channels
Subsubsection 4.1.2: K-Factors full prediction
Subsection 4.2: Gluon channel
Subsubsection 4.2.1: Ratio gluon channel
Subsubsection 4.2.2: K-Factors gluon channel
Section 5: CDF jets
Subsection 5.1: All channels
Subsubsection 5.1.1: Ratio all channels
Subsubsection 5.1.2: K-Factors full prediction
Subsection 5.2: Gluon channel
Subsubsection 5.2.1: Ratio gluon channel
Subsubsection 5.2.2: K-Factors gluon channel
Section 6: D0 jets
Subsection 6.1: All channels
Subsubsection 6.1.1: Ratio all channels
Subsubsection 6.1.2: K-Factors full prediction
Subsection 6.2: Gluon channel
Subsubsection 6.2.1: Ratio gluon channel
Subsubsection 6.2.2: K-Factors gluon channel


1 Summary

This document is an extension of the paper in which we compare the impact of jet predictions on real experimental setups. For a full description of the results please refer to the original paper. Here we provide the full analysis where
  • predictions are computed with the NNPDF23_nnlo_as_0118 replica 0.
  • for each experiment (CMS, ATLAS, CDF and D0) we show predictions using all channels and gg channel normalized to experimental data.
  • we provide several k-factors, which are used to compare the accuracy at LO and NLO order between the approximated codes (NJA and threshold resummation codes) and the exact computation. Also the NNLO/NLO k-factors are provided using the threshold approximation computation and the exact results for the gg channel.
  • the k-factors plots are followed by tables where we show for each bin: the experimental value and its uncertainty, the k-factors using the exact and the threshold approximation results and their relative difference, in particular for the gg channel we also provide the threshold k-factor normalized to the exact NLO, together with its relative difference.
The structure of this document is the same for all experiments.


2 CMS 2011 7 TeV

2.1 All channels

figure cms-bin1.png
Figure 1 Jet predictions using all channels.
figure cms-bin2.png
Figure 2 Jet predictions using all channels.
figure cms-bin3.png
Figure 3 Jet predictions using all channels.
figure cms-bin4.png
Figure 4 Jet predictions using all channels.
figure cms-bin5.png
Figure 5 Jet predictions using all channels.


2.1.1 Ratio all channels

figure cms-bin1-ratio.png figure cms-bin2-ratio.png

figure cms-bin3-ratio.png figure cms-bin4-ratio.png

figure cms-bin5-ratio.png
Figure 6 


2.1.2 K-Factors full prediction

K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 2.6410e+03 7.6605 1.3048 1.2659 -2.98
2 1.2183e+03 7.1542 1.2707 1.2386 -2.53
3 5.8988e+02 6.8006 1.2446 1.2168 -2.23
4 2.9063e+02 6.4464 1.223 1.1986 -2.00
5 1.5159e+02 6.1977 1.2064 1.1832 -1.92
6 8.1069e+01 6.1166 1.1885 1.1701 -1.55
7 4.3880e+01 6.0166 1.1784 1.1607 -1.50
8 2.3974e+01 6.069 1.1651 1.1494 -1.35
9 1.3433e+01 5.8344 1.1552 1.1423 -1.12
10 7.5741e+00 5.9214 1.1498 1.1344 -1.34
11 4.3578e+00 5.9103 1.1399 1.1304 -0.83
12 2.5573e+00 5.977 1.1328 1.1233 -0.84
13 1.4881e+00 6.0889 1.1293 1.1189 -0.92
14 8.5545e-01 6.2194 1.1227 1.1142 -0.76
15 5.0729e-01 6.3535 1.1189 1.1113 -0.68
16 3.0281e-01 6.5094 1.1146 1.108 -0.59
17 1.7834e-01 6.685 1.1126 1.1056 -0.63
18 1.0597e-01 6.88 1.1102 1.1059 -0.39
19 6.2975e-02 7.1088 1.1076 1.1021 -0.50
20 3.7135e-02 7.4039 1.1076 1.1018 -0.52
21 2.1920e-02 7.7549 1.1054 1.1005 -0.44
22 1.2961e-02 8.0812 1.1059 1.1003 -0.51
23 7.4565e-03 8.5314 1.1061 1.1018 -0.39
24 4.1735e-03 9.069 1.107 1.1024 -0.42
25 2.3067e-03 9.7573 1.1077 1.1045 -0.29
26 1.4581e-03 10.5009 1.1117 1.1056 -0.55
27 7.9732e-04 11.6712 1.1113 1.1074 -0.35
28 3.3575e-04 13.8014 1.1151 1.1092 -0.53
29 1.7796e-04 16.6186 1.1191 1.1123 -0.61
30 9.4376e-05 20.234 1.1226 1.116 -0.59
31 4.3007e-05 24.8406 1.1288 1.1211 -0.68
32 1.6149e-05 31.2363 1.1349 1.1257 -0.81
33 2.0397e-06 74.2223 1.1504 1.1395 -0.95
Average 11.38% 14.57% 13.42% -0.98%
Table 1 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO
1 2.5139e+03 7.5804 1.3556 1.3116 -3.25
2 1.1242e+03 7.2061 1.322 1.284 -2.87
3 5.3237e+02 6.7691 1.2945 1.2606 -2.62
4 2.6596e+02 6.399 1.2715 1.2432 -2.23
5 1.3774e+02 6.2308 1.2503 1.227 -1.86
6 7.2171e+01 6.0829 1.2333 1.2138 -1.58
7 3.8690e+01 6.054 1.2197 1.2035 -1.33
8 2.1313e+01 6.0825 1.2086 1.1941 -1.20
9 1.1977e+01 5.8952 1.1965 1.1842 -1.03
10 6.7334e+00 5.9827 1.1834 1.177 -0.54
11 3.8290e+00 6.0043 1.1795 1.1724 -0.60
12 2.2126e+00 6.1054 1.1726 1.168 -0.39
13 1.2718e+00 6.2587 1.164 1.1624 -0.14
14 7.3168e-01 6.4106 1.1611 1.1595 -0.14
15 4.1588e-01 6.5276 1.1528 1.1551 0.20
16 2.4081e-01 6.738 1.1515 1.1541 0.23
17 1.4048e-01 6.9955 1.1504 1.154 0.31
18 8.1789e-02 7.2416 1.1469 1.1529 0.52
19 4.7098e-02 7.5424 1.1439 1.1523 0.73
20 2.7347e-02 7.8865 1.1438 1.1504 0.58
21 1.5332e-02 8.2945 1.1436 1.1508 0.63
22 8.2629e-03 8.7298 1.1424 1.1518 0.82
23 4.3435e-03 9.3245 1.1434 1.1529 0.83
24 2.3794e-03 10.0224 1.1404 1.1525 1.06
25 1.4168e-03 10.8797 1.1465 1.1558 0.81
26 7.6208e-04 11.9879 1.1459 1.1569 0.96
27 3.2068e-04 14.3091 1.1487 1.1594 0.93
28 1.2875e-04 18.0032 1.1507 1.1622 1.00
29 7.1113e-05 23.8937 1.1541 1.164 0.86
30 1.5280e-05 24.9748 1.1608 1.1679 0.61
Average 9.08% 18.59% 18.18% -0.29%
Table 2 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO
1 2.1264e+03 8.5345 1.4686 1.4093 -4.04
2 9.4841e+02 7.9455 1.4272 1.3789 -3.38
3 4.4306e+02 7.4404 1.3938 1.3522 -2.98
4 2.1618e+02 7.0173 1.3659 1.3327 -2.43
5 1.1088e+02 6.8155 1.3432 1.3183 -1.85
6 5.8338e+01 6.6866 1.3246 1.304 -1.56
7 3.0596e+01 6.6694 1.3063 1.2922 -1.08
8 1.5963e+01 6.7146 1.2941 1.2846 -0.73
9 8.7895e+00 6.5443 1.2834 1.2777 -0.44
10 4.8448e+00 6.61 1.2746 1.2728 -0.14
11 2.6745e+00 6.6891 1.2686 1.2714 0.22
12 1.4883e+00 6.8523 1.2601 1.2676 0.60
13 8.1723e-01 7.0222 1.2583 1.2686 0.82
14 4.5003e-01 7.2568 1.2563 1.2672 0.87
15 2.5032e-01 7.4706 1.2494 1.2678 1.47
16 1.3720e-01 7.7755 1.2516 1.2699 1.46
17 7.3806e-02 8.0491 1.2504 1.2721 1.74
18 3.9477e-02 8.4148 1.2522 1.2746 1.79
19 2.0829e-02 8.8651 1.2546 1.2793 1.97
20 1.0519e-02 9.3896 1.2543 1.2825 2.25
21 5.2512e-03 9.9822 1.2562 1.2876 2.50
22 2.6204e-03 10.7199 1.2624 1.2921 2.35
23 1.2672e-03 11.7867 1.2652 1.298 2.59
24 5.3787e-04 13.4865 1.27 1.3027 2.57
25 2.6212e-04 15.7051 1.2744 1.3078 2.62
26 1.4076e-04 20.3736 1.2783 1.3114 2.59
27 8.7777e-06 28.6887 1.2915 1.3208 2.27
Average 9.6% 29.39% 29.86% 0.45%
Table 3 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO
1 1.6383e+03 9.8283 1.6346 1.5544 -4.91
2 7.2786e+02 9.4308 1.5914 1.5253 -4.15
3 3.3039e+02 9.2082 1.5568 1.5033 -3.44
4 1.5735e+02 8.903 1.5253 1.4836 -2.73
5 7.8425e+01 8.987 1.5026 1.4749 -1.84
6 3.8482e+01 9.0353 1.4868 1.4653 -1.45
7 2.0336e+01 9.2203 1.4771 1.4625 -0.99
8 1.0188e+01 9.5409 1.4637 1.4596 -0.28
9 5.3698e+00 9.5504 1.4628 1.4652 0.16
10 2.7229e+00 9.8758 1.4592 1.4708 0.79
11 1.3901e+00 10.1572 1.4635 1.4793 1.08
12 7.2674e-01 10.6264 1.4652 1.487 1.49
13 3.5895e-01 11.0987 1.4699 1.4983 1.93
14 1.8085e-01 11.7454 1.477 1.5106 2.27
15 8.4817e-02 12.1609 1.4858 1.527 2.77
16 3.8799e-02 12.7936 1.5043 1.5429 2.57
17 1.7787e-02 13.5213 1.5103 1.5623 3.44
18 8.1318e-03 14.3923 1.5316 1.5837 3.40
19 3.5729e-03 15.4557 1.5512 1.6066 3.57
20 1.4427e-03 16.8527 1.5726 1.6286 3.56
21 5.0721e-04 19.2402 1.5951 1.6577 3.92
22 1.8119e-04 23.5419 1.6342 1.6912 3.49
23 7.2472e-05 30.0012 1.6648 1.7316 4.01
24 1.0486e-05 37.2034 1.753 1.8065 3.05
Average 13.85% 53.50% 54.91% 0.91%
Table 4 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO
1 1.1132e+03 14.1934 1.8975 1.7812 -6.13
2 4.7126e+02 14.1554 1.8567 1.7645 -4.97
3 2.1037e+02 14.375 1.8202 1.7495 -3.88
4 9.5500e+01 14.4644 1.813 1.7533 -3.29
5 4.2179e+01 14.8869 1.7999 1.763 -2.05
6 1.9811e+01 15.3918 1.8044 1.7778 -1.47
7 9.1229e+00 16.0282 1.8095 1.7987 -0.60
8 3.9568e+00 16.9358 1.8345 1.8296 -0.27
9 1.7580e+00 17.2414 1.8493 1.8648 0.84
10 7.6681e-01 18.0971 1.879 1.9066 1.47
11 3.1497e-01 18.9133 1.9241 1.9601 1.87
12 1.2120e-01 19.9428 1.9513 2.0129 3.16
13 4.6228e-02 21.1426 2.0158 2.0733 2.85
14 1.6192e-02 22.6955 2.0728 2.1516 3.80
15 5.3245e-03 23.3028 2.1636 2.244 3.72
16 1.6421e-03 25.1682 2.275 2.3638 3.90
17 3.2618e-04 28.8786 2.4168 2.5276 4.58
18 9.2622e-05 36.9091 2.6341 2.7535 4.53
19 8.1124e-06 52.9953 3.0689 3.1458 2.51
Average 21.35% 104.6% 106.4% 0.56%
Table 5 


2.2 Gluon channel

figure cms-bin1gg.png
Figure 7 
figure cms-bin2gg.png
Figure 8 
figure cms-bin3gg.png
Figure 9 
figure cms-bin4gg.png
Figure 10 
figure cms-bin5gg.png
Figure 11 


2.2.1 Ratio gluon channel

figure cms-bin1gg-ratio.png figure cms-bin2gg-ratio.png

figure cms-bin3gg-ratio.png figure cms-bin4gg-ratio.png

figure cms-bin5gg-ratio.png
Figure 12 


2.2.2 K-Factors gluon channel

gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 2.6410e+03 7.6605 1.1604 1.2129 4.52 1.1685 1.2129 3.80
2 1.2183e+03 7.1542 1.1494 1.1932 3.81 1.1483 1.1932 3.91
3 5.8988e+02 6.8006 1.1507 1.1771 2.29 1.1327 1.1771 3.92
4 2.9063e+02 6.4464 1.1393 1.1649 2.25 1.1214 1.1649 3.88
5 1.5159e+02 6.1977 1.1372 1.1545 1.52 1.1123 1.1545 3.79
6 8.1069e+01 6.1166 1.1315 1.1453 1.22 1.1032 1.1453 3.82
7 4.3880e+01 6.0166 1.1326 1.1406 0.71 1.0994 1.1406 3.75
8 2.3974e+01 6.069 1.1486 1.1333 -1.33 1.0931 1.1333 3.68
9 1.3433e+01 5.8344 1.129 1.1295 0.04 1.0907 1.1295 3.56
10 7.5741e+00 5.9214 1.1364 1.1253 -0.98 1.0881 1.1253 3.42
11 4.3578e+00 5.9103 1.1417 1.125 -1.46 1.0872 1.125 3.48
12 2.5573e+00 5.977 1.1356 1.122 -1.20 1.0848 1.122 3.43
13 1.4881e+00 6.0889 1.1383 1.1208 -1.54 1.0866 1.1208 3.15
14 8.5545e-01 6.2194 1.1269 1.1192 -0.68 1.0856 1.1192 3.10
15 5.0729e-01 6.3535 1.1374 1.119 -1.62 1.0849 1.119 3.14
16 3.0281e-01 6.5094 1.1345 1.1191 -1.36 1.0885 1.1191 2.81
17 1.7834e-01 6.685 1.1432 1.1193 -2.09 1.0875 1.1193 2.92
18 1.0597e-01 6.88 1.1398 1.1228 -1.49 1.0909 1.1228 2.92
19 6.2975e-02 7.1088 1.1458 1.1215 -2.12 1.0915 1.1215 2.75
20 3.7135e-02 7.4039 1.1518 1.1244 -2.38 1.0939 1.1244 2.79
21 2.1920e-02 7.7549 1.1466 1.1266 -1.74 1.0981 1.1266 2.60
22 1.2961e-02 8.0812 1.1445 1.129 -1.35 1.1022 1.129 2.43
23 7.4565e-03 8.5314 1.1682 1.1347 -2.87 1.11 1.1347 2.23
24 4.1735e-03 9.069 1.1489 1.1393 -0.84 1.1093 1.1393 2.70
25 2.3067e-03 9.7573 1.1701 1.1455 -2.10 1.1219 1.1455 2.10
26 1.4581e-03 10.5009 1.1676 1.1506 -1.46 1.1312 1.1506 1.71
27 7.9732e-04 11.6712 1.1657 1.1583 -0.63 1.1371 1.1583 1.86
28 3.3575e-04 13.8014 1.176 1.1651 -0.93 1.1434 1.1651 1.90
29 1.7796e-04 16.6186 1.1895 1.1746 -1.25 1.1563 1.1746 1.58
30 9.4376e-05 20.234 1.1972 1.1853 -0.99 1.1703 1.1853 1.28
31 4.3007e-05 24.8406 1.2009 1.1982 -0.22 1.1879 1.1982 0.87
32 1.6149e-05 31.2363 1.2171 1.2165 -0.05 1.2071 1.2165 0.78
33 2.0397e-06 74.2223 1.2492 1.2532 0.32 1.2508 1.2532 0.19
Average 11.38% 15.6% 15.1% -0.5% 12% 15.1% 2.7%
Table 6 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO
1 2.5139e+03 7.5804 1.1542 1.2592 9.10 1.2159 1.2592 3.56
2 1.1242e+03 7.2061 1.1388 1.2379 8.70 1.193 1.2379 3.76
3 5.3237e+02 6.7691 1.149 1.2203 6.21 1.176 1.2203 3.77
4 2.6596e+02 6.399 1.138 1.2079 6.14 1.1626 1.2079 3.90
5 1.3774e+02 6.2308 1.1373 1.1955 5.12 1.1501 1.1955 3.95
6 7.2171e+01 6.0829 1.131 1.1853 4.80 1.1406 1.1853 3.92
7 3.8690e+01 6.054 1.1417 1.178 3.18 1.1321 1.178 4.05
8 2.1313e+01 6.0825 1.1254 1.1722 4.16 1.1274 1.1722 3.97
9 1.1977e+01 5.8952 1.1289 1.165 3.20 1.1207 1.165 3.95
10 6.7334e+00 5.9827 1.1307 1.1593 2.53 1.1157 1.1593 3.91
11 3.8290e+00 6.0043 1.1362 1.1575 1.87 1.113 1.1575 4.00
12 2.2126e+00 6.1054 1.1361 1.1545 1.62 1.1104 1.1545 3.97
13 1.2718e+00 6.2587 1.1404 1.1509 0.92 1.109 1.1509 3.78
14 7.3168e-01 6.4106 1.1304 1.1502 1.75 1.1075 1.1502 3.86
15 4.1588e-01 6.5276 1.1398 1.1476 0.68 1.104 1.1476 3.95
16 2.4081e-01 6.738 1.126 1.1483 1.98 1.1037 1.1483 4.04
17 1.4048e-01 6.9955 1.1478 1.1502 0.21 1.1089 1.1502 3.72
18 8.1789e-02 7.2416 1.1614 1.1508 -0.91 1.106 1.1508 4.05
19 4.7098e-02 7.5424 1.1451 1.1519 0.59 1.1087 1.1519 3.90
20 2.7347e-02 7.8865 1.1501 1.1525 0.21 1.11 1.1525 3.83
21 1.5332e-02 8.2945 1.1652 1.1549 -0.88 1.1169 1.1549 3.40
22 8.2629e-03 8.7298 1.1592 1.1597 0.04 1.1205 1.1597 3.50
23 4.3435e-03 9.3245 1.1578 1.1633 0.48 1.1248 1.1633 3.42
24 2.3794e-03 10.0224 1.1859 1.1668 -1.61 1.1308 1.1668 3.18
25 1.4168e-03 10.8797 1.1695 1.1746 0.44 1.139 1.1746 3.13
26 7.6208e-04 11.9879 1.1779 1.1803 0.20 1.1519 1.1803 2.47
27 3.2068e-04 14.3091 1.1843 1.1898 0.46 1.164 1.1898 2.22
28 1.2875e-04 18.0032 1.1881 1.1986 0.88 1.1732 1.1986 2.17
29 7.1113e-05 23.8937 1.2097 1.21 0.02 1.1869 1.21 1.95
30 1.5280e-05 24.9748 1.224 1.2273 0.27 1.2092 1.2273 1.50
Average 9.08% 15.4% 17.7% 2.1% 13.8% 17.7% 3.5%
Table 7 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO
1 2.1264e+03 8.5345 1.1464 1.3606 18.68 1.3193 1.3606 3.13
2 9.4841e+02 7.9455 1.154 1.3343 15.62 1.2906 1.3343 3.39
3 4.4306e+02 7.4404 1.1424 1.3102 14.69 1.2648 1.3102 3.59
4 2.1618e+02 7.0173 1.1386 1.2929 13.55 1.2443 1.2929 3.91
5 1.1088e+02 6.8155 1.1384 1.2802 12.46 1.23 1.2802 4.08
6 5.8338e+01 6.6866 1.1465 1.267 10.51 1.2159 1.267 4.20
7 3.0596e+01 6.6694 1.1275 1.2556 11.36 1.2032 1.2556 4.36
8 1.5963e+01 6.7146 1.1548 1.2484 8.11 1.1951 1.2484 4.46
9 8.7895e+00 6.5443 1.1409 1.2403 8.71 1.1867 1.2403 4.52
10 4.8448e+00 6.61 1.1311 1.2355 9.23 1.1807 1.2355 4.64
11 2.6745e+00 6.6891 1.128 1.2317 9.19 1.1747 1.2317 4.85
12 1.4883e+00 6.8523 1.1442 1.2273 7.26 1.1677 1.2273 5.10
13 8.1723e-01 7.0222 1.1385 1.2264 7.72 1.1708 1.2264 4.75
14 4.5003e-01 7.2568 1.1408 1.2243 7.32 1.1691 1.2243 4.72
15 2.5032e-01 7.4706 1.152 1.2231 6.17 1.1688 1.2231 4.65
16 1.3720e-01 7.7755 1.1439 1.2243 7.03 1.1629 1.2243 5.28
17 7.3806e-02 8.0491 1.1394 1.2248 7.50 1.1658 1.2248 5.06
18 3.9477e-02 8.4148 1.1554 1.2269 6.19 1.17 1.2269 4.86
19 2.0829e-02 8.8651 1.1597 1.2311 6.16 1.1772 1.2311 4.58
20 1.0519e-02 9.3896 1.1663 1.2338 5.79 1.1742 1.2338 5.08
21 5.2512e-03 9.9822 1.1661 1.2401 6.35 1.1848 1.2401 4.67
22 2.6204e-03 10.7199 1.1669 1.2429 6.51 1.1969 1.2429 3.84
23 1.2672e-03 11.7867 1.2002 1.2528 4.38 1.2041 1.2528 4.04
24 5.3787e-04 13.4865 1.1923 1.2589 5.59 1.2036 1.2589 4.59
25 2.6212e-04 15.7051 1.2056 1.2696 5.31 1.2149 1.2696 4.50
26 1.4076e-04 20.3736 1.2039 1.2788 6.22 1.24 1.2788 3.13
27 8.7777e-06 28.6887 1.2271 1.2983 5.80 1.2735 1.2983 1.95
Average 9.6% 15.7% 25.7% 8.6% 20.6% 25.7% 4.3%
Table 8 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO
1 1.6383e+03 9.8283 1.1528 1.5131 31.25 1.4825 1.5131 2.06
2 7.2786e+02 9.4308 1.1491 1.4836 29.11 1.444 1.4836 2.74
3 3.3039e+02 9.2082 1.1511 1.4595 26.79 1.414 1.4595 3.22
4 1.5735e+02 8.903 1.1492 1.4359 24.95 1.3865 1.4359 3.56
5 7.8425e+01 8.987 1.1577 1.4236 22.97 1.3671 1.4236 4.13
6 3.8482e+01 9.0353 1.1385 1.4091 23.77 1.3517 1.4091 4.25
7 2.0336e+01 9.2203 1.1418 1.4005 22.66 1.337 1.4005 4.75
8 1.0188e+01 9.5409 1.155 1.3918 20.50 1.3271 1.3918 4.88
9 5.3698e+00 9.5504 1.1448 1.3903 21.44 1.3193 1.3903 5.38
10 2.7229e+00 9.8758 1.1593 1.3885 19.77 1.3187 1.3885 5.29
11 1.3901e+00 10.1572 1.1481 1.3876 20.86 1.3145 1.3876 5.56
12 7.2674e-01 10.6264 1.1346 1.3882 22.35 1.3096 1.3882 6.00
13 3.5895e-01 11.0987 1.1555 1.3901 20.30 1.3134 1.3901 5.84
14 1.8085e-01 11.7454 1.1618 1.3921 19.82 1.3157 1.3921 5.81
15 8.4817e-02 12.1609 1.1716 1.3991 19.42 1.3165 1.3991 6.27
16 3.8799e-02 12.7936 1.1609 1.4051 21.04 1.3176 1.4051 6.64
17 1.7787e-02 13.5213 1.1789 1.4144 19.98 1.3336 1.4144 6.06
18 8.1318e-03 14.3923 1.1836 1.427 20.56 1.3349 1.427 6.90
19 3.5729e-03 15.4557 1.1845 1.4395 21.53 1.36 1.4395 5.85
20 1.4427e-03 16.8527 1.1866 1.4546 22.59 1.391 1.4546 4.57
21 5.0721e-04 19.2402 1.2051 1.4808 22.88 1.4011 1.4808 5.69
22 1.8119e-04 23.5419 1.2075 1.5142 25.40 1.4325 1.5142 5.70
23 7.2472e-05 30.0012 1.2098 1.5437 27.60 1.5079 1.5437 2.37
24 1.0486e-05 37.2034 1.2099 1.5484 27.98 1.5125 1.5484 2.37
Average 13.85% 16.7% 43.7% 23.1% 37.1% 43.7% 4.8%
Table 9 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO
1 1.1132e+03 14.1934 1.1456 1.7432 52.16 1.7273 1.7432 0.92
2 4.7126e+02 14.1554 1.1492 1.7157 49.30 1.6835 1.7157 1.91
3 2.1037e+02 14.375 1.1575 1.6903 46.03 1.6466 1.6903 2.65
4 9.5500e+01 14.4644 1.1525 1.6788 45.67 1.6254 1.6788 3.29
5 4.2179e+01 14.8869 1.159 1.6734 44.38 1.608 1.6734 4.07
6 1.9811e+01 15.3918 1.165 1.6704 43.38 1.5994 1.6704 4.44
7 9.1229e+00 16.0282 1.1427 1.6725 46.36 1.5931 1.6725 4.98
8 3.9568e+00 16.9358 1.154 1.6787 45.47 1.5933 1.6787 5.36
9 1.7580e+00 17.2414 1.1752 1.6929 44.05 1.5988 1.6929 5.89
10 7.6681e-01 18.0971 1.1567 1.7049 47.39 1.6091 1.7049 5.95
11 3.1497e-01 18.9133 1.1775 1.7329 47.17 1.6324 1.7329 6.16
12 1.2120e-01 19.9428 1.1814 1.753 48.38 1.6388 1.753 6.97
13 4.6228e-02 21.1426 1.203 1.7832 48.23 1.6904 1.7832 5.49
14 1.6192e-02 22.6955 1.1958 1.8329 53.28 1.7136 1.8329 6.96
15 5.3245e-03 23.3028 1.1988 1.9006 58.54 1.7871 1.9006 6.35
16 1.6421e-03 25.1682 1.2098 2 65.32 1.9336 2 3.43
17 3.2618e-04 28.8786 1.1516 2.109 83.14 2.0596 2.109 2.40
18 9.2622e-05 36.9091 1.1519 2.0432 77.38 1.9141 2.0432 6.74
19 8.1124e-06 52.9953 1.1825 1.7888 51.27 1.6879 1.7888 5.98
Average 21.35% 16.9% 78.2% 52.5% 70.2% 78.2% 4.7%
Table 10 


3 ATLAS 7 TeV jets

3.1 All channels

figure atlas7-bin1.png
Figure 13 
figure atlas7-bin2.png
Figure 14 
figure atlas7-bin3.png
Figure 15 
figure atlas7-bin4.png
Figure 16 
figure atlas7-bin5.png
Figure 17 
figure atlas7-bin6.png
Figure 18 
figure atlas7-bin7.png
Figure 19 

3.1.1 Ratio all channels

figure atlas7-bin1-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin2-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin3-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin4-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin5-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin6-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin7-ratio.png
Figure 20 


3.1.2 K-Factors full prediction

K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 4.7475e+06 23.3268 2.6353 2.3578 -10.53
2 7.2424e+05 18.5066 2.2195 2.0056 -9.64
3 1.4949e+05 13.9274 1.9058 1.7647 -7.40
4 3.8485e+04 12.0152 1.7111 1.6151 -5.61
5 8.6061e+03 12.261 1.5691 1.4948 -4.74
6 1.4949e+03 10.6946 1.4469 1.387 -4.14
7 2.5400e+02 11.2422 1.3458 1.3017 -3.28
8 6.3400e+01 14.0325 1.2853 1.2529 -2.52
9 2.0700e+01 13.1113 1.2535 1.2177 -2.86
10 5.9600e+00 12.046 1.2143 1.1886 -2.12
11 1.3300e+00 12.7419 1.1898 1.1606 -2.45
12 3.4700e-01 14.693 1.1604 1.1386 -1.88
13 6.4400e-02 16.3403 1.1479 1.1245 -2.04
14 1.0100e-02 24.3375 1.1303 1.111 -1.71
15 1.1400e-03 43.0001 1.1265 1.1046 -1.94
16 4.0000e-04 64.3242 1.1249 1.1051 -1.76
Average 19.8% 46.7% 39.6% -4.04%
Table 11 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 4.7041e+06 23.275 2.822 2.4117 -14.54
2 7.3737e+05 18.9232 2.3149 2.0521 -11.35
3 1.5051e+05 14.1032 1.9703 1.8076 -8.26
4 3.7475e+04 12.0853 1.7833 1.6592 -6.96
5 8.4343e+03 11.4745 1.6372 1.5323 -6.41
6 1.4545e+03 11.7405 1.4929 1.4234 -4.66
7 2.4343e+02 12.0632 1.3868 1.3324 -3.92
8 6.0600e+01 13.2759 1.3311 1.2806 -3.79
9 1.9600e+01 13.3945 1.287 1.2492 -2.94
10 5.6400e+00 14.0202 1.2509 1.2195 -2.51
11 1.1900e+00 14.0031 1.2218 1.1921 -2.43
12 3.1600e-01 15.1863 1.1964 1.1736 -1.91
13 6.6000e-02 17.3743 1.1797 1.1597 -1.70
14 7.8000e-03 23.7402 1.167 1.1518 -1.30
15 1.3800e-03 38.8769 1.1586 1.1466 -1.04
16 2.3500e-04 73.3069 1.16 1.1468 -1.14
Average 20.4% 52.2% 43.4% -4.68%
Table 12 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 4.0000e+06 27.1532 3.0037 2.5167 -16.21
2 6.7959e+05 20.6534 2.5031 2.1617 -13.64
3 1.4040e+05 15.5795 2.0935 1.9081 -8.86
4 3.4242e+04 12.8432 1.9213 1.7537 -8.72
5 7.6263e+03 12.4546 1.7454 1.6256 -6.86
6 1.2929e+03 12.3535 1.5976 1.5083 -5.59
7 2.0707e+02 12.6587 1.4607 1.4122 -3.32
8 5.0100e+01 13.8718 1.4044 1.3599 -3.17
9 1.5900e+01 14.1359 1.3657 1.3249 -2.99
10 4.3800e+00 14.2512 1.3227 1.3 -1.72
11 9.1800e-01 15.507 1.2885 1.2765 -0.93
12 2.1400e-01 16.8993 1.278 1.2642 -1.08
13 4.0700e-02 20.2256 1.2628 1.2632 0.03
14 2.7000e-03 32.8892 1.2612 1.2653 0.33
15 4.6600e-04 69.3513 1.2588 1.2731 1.14
16 1.0200e-04 113.3008 1.2742 1.2895 1.20
Average 26.5% 62.7% 53.1% -4.4%
Table 13 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 3.8144e+06 28.3609 3.5675 2.7916 -21.75
2 5.7938e+05 23.1683 2.9085 2.4185 -16.85
3 1.1122e+05 17.3887 2.5163 2.1545 -14.38
4 2.7245e+04 14.9045 2.2491 1.9852 -11.73
5 5.9592e+03 13.5442 2.0227 1.843 -8.88
6 9.6768e+02 12.2931 1.8468 1.7161 -7.08
7 1.5253e+02 13.6862 1.703 1.6132 -5.27
8 3.4141e+01 14.5209 1.6234 1.5673 -3.46
9 9.6768e+00 15.9416 1.5819 1.542 -2.52
10 2.3500e+00 16.5515 1.5497 1.5295 -1.30
11 3.9100e-01 18.4577 1.524 1.5234 -0.04
12 7.2500e-02 21.7 1.511 1.5193 0.55
13 9.5100e-03 27.6168 1.4912 1.5174 1.76
14 4.8600e-04 51.7804 1.4918 1.5283 2.45
15 6.9300e-05 112.4636 1.5155 1.5605 2.97
Average 26.8% 94.0% 78.7% -5.7%
Table 14 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 2.8750e+06 35.9715 4.5541 3.2556 -28.51
2 4.2396e+05 30.3757 3.7209 2.868 -22.92
3 8.2474e+04 20.5697 3.144 2.583 -17.84
4 1.7629e+04 16.4221 2.8429 2.3997 -15.59
5 3.5102e+03 13.8806 2.5544 2.2627 -11.42
6 5.0816e+02 14.279 2.4053 2.175 -9.57
7 5.9899e+01 16.5848 2.2699 2.1573 -4.96
8 1.0101e+01 19.9705 2.2806 2.2066 -3.24
9 1.8687e+00 21.4024 2.3153 2.2858 -1.27
10 2.7879e-01 27.9207 2.3831 2.3874 0.18
11 1.6600e-02 37.8399 2.5727 2.6267 2.10
12 3.1300e-04 96.5422 3.0076 3.0838 2.53
Average 29.31% 183.6% 52.4% -9.2%
Table 15 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 2.0323e+06 44.9498 5.699 3.771 -33.83
2 2.8404e+05 41.0901 4.6826 3.3858 -27.69
3 4.4737e+04 29.701 4.0645 3.1397 -22.75
4 8.9271e+03 22.2178 3.7078 3.0405 -18.00
5 1.3505e+03 22.0491 3.5864 3.0465 -15.05
6 1.1959e+02 22.3605 3.5407 3.1776 -10.26
7 5.6837e+00 33.596 3.729 3.5136 -5.78
8 2.9490e-01 43.4456 4.2729 4.138 -3.16
9 9.2626e-03 93.156 5.4575 5.3808 -1.41
Average 39.17% 330.4% 262.1% -15.3%
Table 16 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 9.1000e+05 64.4667 7.2521 4.4631 -38.46
2 9.4945e+04 67.1388 6.5818 4.3113 -34.50
3 9.7033e+03 50.5717 6.1462 4.4781 -27.14
4 1.0000e+03 40.8999 6.5186 4.8591 -25.46
5 5.8478e+01 38.009 7.0378 5.6304 -20.00
6 5.8913e-01 52.7968 7.5364 8.0077 6.25
Average 52.31% 584.5% 429.2% -23.2%
Table 17 


3.2 Gluon channel

figure atlas7-bin1gg.png
Figure 21 
figure atlas7-bin2gg.png
Figure 22 
figure atlas7-bin3gg.png
Figure 23 
figure atlas7-bin4gg.png
Figure 24 
figure atlas7-bin5gg.png
Figure 25 
figure atlas7-bin6gg.png
Figure 26 
figure atlas7-bin7gg.png
Figure 27 


3.2.1 Ratio gluon channel

figure atlas7-bin1gg-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin2gg-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin3gg-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin4gg-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin5gg-ratio.png figure atlas7-bin6gg-ratio.png

figure atlas7-bin7gg-ratio.png
Figure 28 


3.2.2 K-Factors gluon channel

gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 4.7475e+06 23.3268 1.1405 2.1444 88.02 2.176 2.1444 -1.45
2 7.2424e+05 18.5066 1.0848 1.8308 68.77 1.8118 1.8308 1.05
3 1.4949e+05 13.9274 1.0779 1.6208 50.37 1.5817 1.6208 2.47
4 3.8485e+04 12.0152 1.0383 1.4933 43.82 1.4502 1.4933 2.97
5 8.6061e+03 12.261 1.0486 1.3936 32.90 1.3497 1.3936 3.25
6 1.4949e+03 10.6946 1.0675 1.3075 22.48 1.2645 1.3075 3.40
7 2.5400e+02 11.2422 1.0427 1.2411 19.03 1.1976 1.2411 3.63
8 6.3400e+01 14.0325 1.0346 1.2048 16.45 1.1655 1.2048 3.37
9 2.0700e+01 13.1113 1.0487 1.1798 12.50 1.1422 1.1798 3.29
10 5.9600e+00 12.046 1.0438 1.1609 11.22 1.1278 1.1609 2.93
11 1.3300e+00 12.7419 1.0634 1.1447 7.65 1.1077 1.1447 3.34
12 3.4700e-01 14.693 1.0546 1.1308 7.23 1.1026 1.1308 2.56
13 6.4400e-02 16.3403 1.0499 1.1258 7.23 1.0916 1.1258 3.13
14 1.0100e-02 24.3375 1.056 1.1211 6.16 1.0934 1.1211 2.53
15 1.1400e-03 43.0001 1.0774 1.1227 4.20 1.105 1.1227 1.60
16 4.0000e-04 64.3242 1.0591 1.1327 6.95 1.1114 1.1327 1.92
Average 19.8% 6.2% 33.5% 25.3% 30.5% 33.5% 2.5%
Table 18 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 4.7041e+06 23.275 1.0949 2.2051 101.40 2.2597 2.2051 -2.42
2 7.3737e+05 18.9232 1.0858 1.8855 73.65 1.882 1.8855 0.19
3 1.5051e+05 14.1032 1.0638 1.6706 57.04 1.643 1.6706 1.68
4 3.7475e+04 12.0853 1.0535 1.542 46.37 1.5039 1.542 2.53
5 8.4343e+03 11.4745 1.0429 1.436 37.69 1.3944 1.436 2.98
6 1.4545e+03 11.7405 1.0502 1.3483 28.39 1.3059 1.3483 3.25
7 2.4343e+02 12.0632 1.0399 1.2758 22.68 1.2315 1.2758 3.60
8 6.0600e+01 13.2759 1.0255 1.2361 20.54 1.1958 1.2361 3.37
9 1.9600e+01 13.3945 1.0273 1.2129 18.07 1.168 1.2129 3.84
10 5.6400e+00 14.0202 1.0355 1.1914 15.06 1.1495 1.1914 3.65
11 1.1900e+00 14.0031 1.0427 1.1729 12.49 1.1413 1.1729 2.77
12 3.1600e-01 15.1863 1.0344 1.159 12.05 1.1238 1.159 3.13
13 6.6000e-02 17.3743 1.0413 1.1513 10.56 1.1176 1.1513 3.02
14 7.8000e-03 23.7402 1.0486 1.1489 9.57 1.118 1.1489 2.76
15 1.3800e-03 38.8769 1.0662 1.1505 7.91 1.1214 1.1505 2.59
16 2.3500e-04 73.3069 1.0726 1.1595 8.10 1.1264 1.1595 2.94
Average 20.4% 5.2% 37.2% 30.1% 34.3% 37.2% 2.5%
Table 19 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 4.0000e+06 27.1532 1.1068 2.3304 110.55 2.4438 2.3304 -4.64
2 6.7959e+05 20.6534 1.1082 2.0116 81.52 2.0448 2.0116 -1.62
3 1.4040e+05 15.5795 1.0721 1.7867 66.65 1.7808 1.7867 0.33
4 3.4242e+04 12.8432 1.0481 1.6531 57.72 1.6305 1.6531 1.39
5 7.6263e+03 12.4546 1.0456 1.5445 47.71 1.5136 1.5445 2.04
6 1.2929e+03 12.3535 1.0497 1.4457 37.73 1.4051 1.4457 2.89
7 2.0707e+02 12.6587 1.0332 1.367 32.31 1.3204 1.367 3.53
8 5.0100e+01 13.8718 1.0586 1.323 24.98 1.2765 1.323 3.64
9 1.5900e+01 14.1359 1.0352 1.2929 24.89 1.2424 1.2929 4.06
10 4.3800e+00 14.2512 1.0362 1.2711 22.67 1.2224 1.2711 3.98
11 9.1800e-01 15.507 1.0553 1.2485 18.31 1.2052 1.2485 3.59
12 2.1400e-01 16.8993 1.055 1.2346 17.02 1.1773 1.2346 4.87
13 4.0700e-02 20.2256 1.0547 1.2328 16.89 1.1807 1.2328 4.41
14 2.7000e-03 32.8892 1.0711 1.232 15.02 1.1665 1.232 5.62
15 4.6600e-04 69.3513 1.0877 1.2384 13.85 1.1774 1.2384 5.18
16 1.0200e-04 113.3008 1.1179 1.2575 12.49 1.21 1.2575 3.93
Average 26.5% 6.5% 46.7% 37.5% 43.7% 46.7% 2.7%
Table 20 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 3.8144e+06 28.3609 1.0859 2.6535 144.36 2.9287 2.6535 -9.40
2 5.7938e+05 23.1683 1.079 2.3145 114.50 2.4513 2.3145 -5.58
3 1.1122e+05 17.3887 1.0492 2.0782 98.07 2.1363 2.0782 -2.72
4 2.7245e+04 14.9045 1.0528 1.9272 83.05 1.9512 1.9272 -1.23
5 5.9592e+03 13.5442 1.0351 1.8033 74.22 1.7962 1.8033 0.40
6 9.6768e+02 12.2931 1.036 1.688 62.93 1.6567 1.688 1.89
7 1.5253e+02 13.6862 1.0465 1.585 51.46 1.5396 1.585 2.95
8 3.4141e+01 14.5209 1.0276 1.533 49.18 1.4709 1.533 4.22
9 9.6768e+00 15.9416 1.0315 1.4963 45.06 1.4328 1.4963 4.43
10 2.3500e+00 16.5515 1.0449 1.4705 40.73 1.3991 1.4705 5.10
11 3.9100e-01 18.4577 1.0499 1.4427 37.41 1.3634 1.4427 5.82
12 7.2500e-02 21.7 1.0403 1.4169 36.20 1.3226 1.4169 7.13
13 9.5100e-03 27.6168 1.0597 1.4036 32.45 1.3252 1.4036 5.92
14 4.8600e-04 51.7804 1.1121 1.4055 26.38 1.3384 1.4055 5.01
15 6.9300e-05 112.4636 1.1182 1.4388 28.67 1.347 1.4388 6.82
Average 26.8% 5.8% 71.1% 61.6% 69.7% 71.1% 2.1%
Table 21 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 2.8750e+06 35.9715 1.0832 3.2222 197.47 3.8805 3.2222 -16.96
2 4.2396e+05 30.3757 1.0753 2.8748 167.35 3.2745 2.8748 -12.21
3 8.2474e+04 20.5697 1.0547 2.625 148.89 2.8555 2.625 -8.07
4 1.7629e+04 16.4221 1.0525 2.463 134.01 2.6046 2.463 -5.44
5 3.5102e+03 13.8806 1.0482 2.3323 122.51 2.4063 2.3323 -3.08
6 5.0816e+02 14.279 1.0436 2.2307 113.75 2.2373 2.2307 -0.29
7 5.9899e+01 16.5848 1.0417 2.1677 108.09 2.1112 2.1677 2.68
8 1.0101e+01 19.9705 1.0456 2.1603 106.61 2.055 2.1603 5.12
9 1.8687e+00 21.4024 1.046 2.1806 108.47 2.0411 2.1806 6.83
10 2.7879e-01 27.9207 1.0446 2.2199 112.51 2.0491 2.2199 8.34
11 1.6600e-02 37.8399 1.0667 2.3796 123.08 2.1761 2.3796 9.35
12 3.1300e-04 96.5422 1.2447 2.7499 120.93 2.769 2.7499 -0.69
Average 29.3% 7.1% 146.7% 130.3% 153.8% 146.7% -1.2%
Table 22 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 2.0323e+06 44.9498 1.049 3.9296 274.60 5.1988 3.9296 -24.41
2 2.8404e+05 41.0901 1.0693 3.6019 236.85 4.4167 3.6019 -18.45
3 4.4737e+04 29.701 1.0441 3.3733 223.08 3.8837 3.3733 -13.14
4 8.9271e+03 22.2178 1.0492 3.2522 209.97 3.6012 3.2522 -9.69
5 1.3505e+03 22.0491 1.0557 3.2034 203.44 3.4039 3.2034 -5.89
6 1.1959e+02 22.3605 1.0341 3.2345 212.78 3.2729 3.2345 -1.17
7 5.6837e+00 33.596 0.9974 3.4406 244.96 3.2884 3.4406 4.63
8 2.9490e-01 43.4456 1.1062 3.9922 260.89 3.7523 3.9922 6.39
9 9.2626e-03 93.156 1.1287 5.659 401.37 4.8168 5.659 17.48
Average 39.2% 5.9% 274.3% 251.9% 295.9% 274.3% -4.9%
Table 23 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 9.1000e+05 64.4667 1.035 4.9707 380.26 7.3006 4.9707 -31.91
2 9.4945e+04 67.1388 1.0528 4.802 356.12 6.401 4.802 -24.98
3 9.7033e+03 50.5717 1.03 4.8858 374.35 5.9346 4.8858 -17.67
4 1.0000e+03 40.8999 1.0079 5.1638 412.33 5.8942 5.1638 -12.39
5 5.8478e+01 38.009 1.0187 5.8867 477.86 6.2008 5.8867 -5.07
6 5.8913e-01 52.7968 0.9229 9.4063 919.21 8.9487 9.4063 5.11
Average 52.3% 1.1% 485.2% 486.7% 578% 485.3% -14.5%
Table 24 


4 ATLAS 2.76 TeV jets

4.1 All channels

figure atlas2-bin1.png
Figure 29 
figure atlas2-bin2.png
Figure 30 
figure atlas2-bin3.png
Figure 31 
figure atlas2-bin4.png
Figure 32 
figure atlas2-bin5.png
Figure 33 
figure atlas2-bin6.png
Figure 34 
figure atlas2-bin7.png
Figure 35 


4.1.1 Ratio all channels

figure atlas2-bin1-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin2-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin3-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin4-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin5-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin6-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin7-ratio.png
Figure 36 


4.1.2 K-Factors full prediction

K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.4864e+03 24.2727 2.1261 1.9772 -7.00
2 2.1374e+02 20.195 1.811 1.6992 -6.17
3 3.5667e+01 14.3507 1.6013 1.5179 -5.21
4 7.7000e+00 12.8376 1.4731 1.4124 -4.12
5 1.4206e+00 13.8038 1.3747 1.3262 -3.53
6 2.0276e-01 12.2458 1.2893 1.2497 -3.07
7 2.5778e-02 15.7923 1.2264 1.1931 -2.72
8 4.2737e-03 24.0877 1.1957 1.1647 -2.59
9 1.2081e-03 41.7325 1.1736 1.1433 -2.58
10 4.3152e-04 48.5072 1.1607 1.1306 -2.59
11 7.1101e-05 116.4275 1.1491 1.1248 -2.11
Average 31.3% 41.6% 35.8% -3.8%
Table 25 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.4818e+03 23.9425 2.3006 2.0411 -11.28
2 2.0736e+02 19.9388 1.9064 1.7594 -7.71
3 3.2989e+01 14.9857 1.6715 1.5675 -6.22
4 7.3589e+00 12.8073 1.5344 1.4572 -5.03
5 1.3990e+00 12.9025 1.4346 1.3699 -4.51
6 1.8980e-01 13.5593 1.3437 1.2933 -3.75
7 2.1495e-02 15.6309 1.2679 1.232 -2.83
8 3.3768e-03 23.7035 1.2332 1.204 -2.37
9 9.8283e-04 35.6697 1.2139 1.1894 -2.02
10 3.6303e-04 47.7796 1.201 1.1812 -1.65
11 8.8899e-05 81.2158 1.1903 1.1742 -1.35
Average 27.5% 48.2% 40.6% -4.4%
Table 26 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.2854e+03 26.9324 2.4748 2.1871 -11.63
2 1.7380e+02 20.4538 2.0697 1.8944 -8.47
3 2.8617e+01 16.2391 1.8088 1.6906 -6.53
4 6.1844e+00 14.789 1.6572 1.57 -5.26
5 1.1827e+00 13.0982 1.5386 1.4742 -4.19
6 1.5232e-01 14.5727 1.4353 1.3923 -3.00
7 1.7313e-02 18.1585 1.3597 1.3406 -1.40
8 2.3051e-03 27.3074 1.3351 1.3227 -0.93
9 6.5778e-04 46.1972 1.3217 1.3186 -0.23
10 5.2980e-05 126.204 1.3121 1.3171 0.38
Average 32.4% 63.1% 55.1% -4.1%
Table 27 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.0631e+03 31.3513 3.0331 2.5353 -16.41
2 1.3804e+02 25.4028 2.5227 2.2084 -12.46
3 2.1351e+01 17.9496 2.1767 1.9788 -9.09
4 4.3594e+00 14.1602 1.9836 1.8438 -7.05
5 7.3959e-01 14.6909 1.8368 1.7509 -4.68
6 8.3714e-02 15.7487 1.7343 1.6861 -2.78
7 9.2384e-03 20.4022 1.658 1.6528 -0.31
8 9.1525e-04 32.1716 1.6286 1.6419 0.82
9 9.0354e-05 81.2976 1.607 1.6374 1.89
10 2.4030e-05 125.8652 1.6185 1.647 1.76
Average 37.9% 97.9% 85.8% -4.8%
Table 28 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 7.1034e+02 40.3484 3.9478 3.1308 -20.70
2 8.4674e+01 32.6038 3.3385 2.7929 -16.34
3 1.0968e+01 22.655 2.9191 2.5984 -10.99
4 1.8989e+00 18.4278 2.7629 2.5477 -7.79
5 2.2594e-01 20.7194 2.7117 2.5872 -4.59
6 1.1698e-02 24.7426 2.7453 2.7237 -0.79
7 5.4844e-04 51.9687 3.0625 3.0997 1.21
8 6.5250e-05 123.3975 3.9094 3.9963 2.22
Average 41.8% 217.5% 193.5% -7.2%
Table 29 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 3.6430e+02 50.2722 5.3374 3.9357 -26.26
2 3.1697e+01 48.5635 4.7785 3.8226 -20.00
3 2.4769e+00 41.0702 4.609 3.9743 -13.77
4 1.9495e-01 36.0109 4.8105 4.3093 -10.42
5 4.9813e-03 37.8164 5.2937 5.1219 -3.25
6 1.6560e-04 92.2274 8.0784 8.1394 0.76
Average 50.9% 448.5% 388.4% -12.2%
Table 30 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 5.9628e+01 102.8591 8.898 6.0433 -32.08
2 1.7051e+00 153.8379 9.7242 7.201 -25.95
3 1.1701e-02 148.6082 14.6776 11.7403 -20.01
Average 135.1% 1010% 732% -26.0%
Table 31 


4.2 Gluon channel

figure atlas2-bin1gg.png
Figure 37 
figure atlas2-bin2gg.png
Figure 38 
figure atlas2-bin3gg.png
Figure 39 
figure atlas2-bin4gg.png
Figure 40 
figure atlas2-bin5gg.png
Figure 41 
figure atlas2-bin6gg.png
Figure 42 
figure atlas2-bin7gg.png
Figure 43 


4.2.1 Ratio gluon channel

figure atlas2-bin1gg-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin2gg-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin3gg-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin4gg-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin5gg-ratio.png figure atlas2-bin6gg-ratio.png

figure atlas2-bin7gg-ratio.png
Figure 44 


4.2.2 K-Factors gluon channel

gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.4864e+03 24.2727 1.0721 1.7853 66.52 1.7372 1.7853 2.77
2 2.1374e+02 20.195 1.0639 1.5548 46.14 1.501 1.5548 3.58
3 3.5667e+01 14.3507 1.0484 1.4088 34.38 1.3558 1.4088 3.91
4 7.7000e+00 12.8376 1.0613 1.3275 25.08 1.2789 1.3275 3.80
5 1.4206e+00 13.8038 1.0452 1.2638 20.91 1.2186 1.2638 3.71
6 2.0276e-01 12.2458 1.0618 1.2108 14.03 1.1715 1.2108 3.35
7 2.5778e-02 15.7923 1.0393 1.174 12.96 1.1431 1.174 2.70
8 4.2737e-03 24.0877 1.0293 1.1584 12.54 1.1282 1.1584 2.68
9 1.2081e-03 41.7325 1.06 1.1464 8.15 1.1147 1.1464 2.84
10 4.3152e-04 48.5072 1.0478 1.1419 8.98 1.1144 1.1419 2.47
11 7.1101e-05 116.4275 1.0627 1.1474 7.97 1.1292 1.1474 1.61
Average 31.3% 5% 30.2% 23.4% 26.3% 30.2% 3.04%
Table 32 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.4818e+03 23.9425 1.0863 1.8582 71.06 1.8202 1.8582 2.09
2 2.0736e+02 19.9388 1.0719 1.6216 51.28 1.5715 1.6216 3.19
3 3.2989e+01 14.9857 1.0246 1.464 42.89 1.4122 1.464 3.67
4 7.3589e+00 12.8073 1.0586 1.3779 30.16 1.3263 1.3779 3.89
5 1.3990e+00 12.9025 1.0398 1.3104 26.02 1.2621 1.3104 3.83
6 1.8980e-01 13.5593 1.0415 1.2539 20.39 1.2101 1.2539 3.62
7 2.1495e-02 15.6309 1.0365 1.2075 16.50 1.1686 1.2075 3.33
8 3.3768e-03 23.7035 1.0441 1.189 13.88 1.153 1.189 3.12
9 9.8283e-04 35.6697 1.048 1.1799 12.59 1.1437 1.1799 3.17
10 3.6303e-04 47.7796 1.0478 1.1774 12.37 1.1431 1.1774 3.00
11 8.8899e-05 81.2158 1.052 1.1804 12.21 1.1443 1.1804 3.15
Average 27.5% 5% 34.7% 28.1% 30.5% 34.7% 3.3%
Table 33 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.2854e+03 26.9324 1.0757 2.0263 88.37 2.0208 2.0263 0.27
2 1.7380e+02 20.4538 1.0475 1.7743 69.38 1.7394 1.7743 2.01
3 2.8617e+01 16.2391 1.0381 1.6024 54.36 1.5549 1.6024 3.05
4 6.1844e+00 14.789 1.0356 1.5034 45.17 1.4511 1.5034 3.60
5 1.1827e+00 13.0982 1.0486 1.4242 35.82 1.3704 1.4242 3.93
6 1.5232e-01 14.5727 1.0454 1.3549 29.61 1.3006 1.3549 4.17
7 1.7313e-02 18.1585 1.0547 1.3066 23.88 1.2502 1.3066 4.51
8 2.3051e-03 27.3074 1.039 1.2871 23.88 1.2309 1.2871 4.57
9 6.5778e-04 46.1972 1.0514 1.2798 21.72 1.2298 1.2798 4.07
10 5.2980e-05 126.204 1.0551 1.275 20.84 1.2148 1.275 4.96
Average 32.4% 4.91% 48.3% 41.3% 43.6% 48.3% 3.5%
Table 34 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.0631e+03 31.3513 1.0773 2.4321 125.76 2.5278 2.4321 -3.79
2 1.3804e+02 25.4028 1.0641 2.145 101.58 2.1559 2.145 -0.51
3 2.1351e+01 17.9496 1.0639 1.9372 82.08 1.904 1.9372 1.74
4 4.3594e+00 14.1602 1.0473 1.8043 72.28 1.7536 1.8043 2.89
5 7.3959e-01 14.6909 1.0501 1.705 62.37 1.6378 1.705 4.10
6 8.3714e-02 15.7487 1.0419 1.6173 55.23 1.5365 1.6173 5.26
7 9.2384e-03 20.4022 1.0441 1.5472 48.19 1.4631 1.5472 5.75
8 9.1525e-04 32.1716 1.0217 1.5095 47.74 1.4002 1.5095 7.81
9 9.0354e-05 81.2976 1.0604 1.4933 40.82 1.4035 1.4933 6.40
10 2.4030e-05 125.8652 1.0772 1.4978 39.05 1.4001 1.4978 6.98
Average 37.9% 5.5% 76.9% 67.5% 71.8% 76.8% 3.6%
Table 35 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 7.1034e+02 40.3484 1.0701 3.2055 199.55 3.558 3.2055 -9.91
2 8.4674e+01 32.6038 1.0175 2.8889 183.92 3.0465 2.8889 -5.17
3 1.0968e+01 22.655 1.0937 2.6712 144.24 2.702 2.6712 -1.14
4 1.8989e+00 18.4278 1.052 2.5724 144.52 2.5342 2.5724 1.51
5 2.2594e-01 20.7194 1.0344 2.5309 144.67 2.4325 2.5309 4.05
6 1.1698e-02 24.7426 1.0123 2.5444 151.35 2.3683 2.5444 7.44
7 5.4844e-04 51.9687 1.0582 2.7866 163.33 2.5084 2.7866 11.09
8 6.5250e-05 123.3975 1.0044 4.8469 382.57 3.8137 4.8469 27.09
Average 41.8% 4.3% 200% 189.3% 187.1% 200% 4.4%
Table 36 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 3.6430e+02 50.2722 1.0306 4.2642 313.76 5.0833 4.2642 -16.11
2 3.1697e+01 48.5635 1.0433 4.0624 289.38 4.4793 4.0624 -9.31
3 2.4769e+00 41.0702 1.033 4.0504 292.10 4.1676 4.0504 -2.81
4 1.9495e-01 36.0109 1.0466 4.2394 305.06 4.144 4.2394 2.30
5 4.9813e-03 37.8164 1.0301 4.9744 382.90 4.6503 4.9744 6.97
6 1.6560e-04 92.2274 1.238 1.1865 -4.16 1.0938 1.1865 8.48
Average 50.9% 7% 279% 263.2% 293.6% 279% -1.8%
Table 37 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 5.9628e+01 102.8591 1.0091 6.5656 550.64 8.3872 6.5656 -21.72
2 1.7051e+00 153.8379 0.9774 7.567 674.20 8.59 7.567 -11.91
3 1.1701e-02 148.6082 0.7618 26.0327 3317.26 16.5523 26.0327 57.28
Average 135.1% -9% 13.4% 1514% 1017.7% 1238.8% 7.9%
Table 38 


5 CDF jets

5.1 All channels

figure cdf-bin1.png
Figure 45 
figure cdf-bin2.png
Figure 46 
figure cdf-bin3.png
Figure 47 
figure cdf-bin4.png
Figure 48 
figure cdf-bin5.png
Figure 49 


5.1.1 Ratio all channels

figure cdf-bin1-ratio.png figure cdf-bin2-ratio.png

figure cdf-bin3-ratio.png figure cdf-bin4-ratio.png

figure cdf-bin5-ratio.png
Figure 50 

5.1.2 K-Factors full prediction

K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.2332e+01 18.3447 1.2846 1.2507 -2.64
2 5.8392e+00 16.3363 1.2488 1.2249 -1.91
3 2.5648e+00 15.1286 1.2244 1.2016 -1.86
4 1.1293e+00 14.1836 1.2013 1.1837 -1.47
5 4.9055e-01 13.6802 1.1818 1.1665 -1.29
6 2.1819e-01 13.5437 1.1654 1.153 -1.06
7 8.8655e-02 13.4586 1.1517 1.1415 -0.89
8 3.4626e-02 13.8317 1.1387 1.1327 -0.53
9 1.3375e-02 14.4361 1.1281 1.1237 -0.39
10 5.0470e-03 15.5616 1.1218 1.1206 -0.11
11 1.7391e-03 16.953 1.1155 1.1164 0.08
12 5.7740e-04 18.58 1.1151 1.1171 0.18
13 1.7438e-04 20.4884 1.1135 1.1162 0.24
14 4.6164e-05 23.1129 1.1145 1.1193 0.43
15 1.2831e-05 27.0039 1.1184 1.1221 0.33
16 2.4676e-06 36.4214 1.125 1.1291 0.36
17 2.1933e-07 58.6463 1.1514 1.1401 -0.98
Average 20.6% 15.9% 15.1% -0.7%
Table 39 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.1773e+01 17.3309 1.3051 1.2733 -2.44
2 5.3141e+00 15.7537 1.2745 1.2472 -2.14
3 2.3850e+00 14.375 1.2468 1.2245 -1.79
4 1.0304e+00 13.4666 1.2231 1.2051 -1.47
5 4.5067e-01 12.9087 1.2003 1.1858 -1.21
6 1.9389e-01 12.6869 1.1853 1.1753 -0.84
7 8.0186e-02 12.7669 1.17 1.162 -0.68
8 3.1674e-02 13.1506 1.1592 1.1535 -0.49
9 1.1795e-02 14.0111 1.1472 1.1462 -0.09
10 4.3733e-03 15.1797 1.1402 1.1423 0.18
11 1.5238e-03 16.7691 1.135 1.1387 0.33
12 4.7637e-04 18.7902 1.1303 1.1384 0.72
13 1.4064e-04 21.2221 1.1298 1.1387 0.79
14 3.6648e-05 24.4097 1.1317 1.1407 0.80
15 7.2081e-06 28.8382 1.1339 1.1443 0.92
16 1.1827e-06 36.0876 1.1433 1.1511 0.68
17 9.3577e-08 53.4882 1.1706 1.1582 -1.06
Average 20.1% 17.8% 17.2% -0.5%
Table 40 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.0490e+01 17.5576 1.3911 1.3588 -2.32
2 4.7944e+00 16.2211 1.3594 1.33 -2.16
3 2.1471e+00 14.8956 1.3262 1.304 -1.67
4 9.1016e-01 14.2023 1.2962 1.2807 -1.20
5 3.8312e-01 13.8172 1.2751 1.2654 -0.76
6 1.6165e-01 13.8845 1.2554 1.2522 -0.25
7 6.4513e-02 14.1844 1.2403 1.2421 0.15
8 2.3995e-02 14.8484 1.2263 1.2326 0.51
9 8.5956e-03 15.8953 1.2181 1.2306 1.03
10 2.9408e-03 17.3788 1.212 1.23 1.49
11 9.2721e-04 19.3332 1.2093 1.2316 1.84
12 2.4773e-04 22.1375 1.2127 1.2364 1.95
13 6.0900e-05 26.0269 1.2116 1.2394 2.29
14 1.1095e-05 31.8232 1.226 1.2502 1.97
15 1.5785e-06 40.2833 1.2373 1.2607 1.89
16 2.3408e-07 57.7304 1.2583 1.271 1.01
Average 21.9% 25.9% 26.3% 0.4%
Table 41 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 9.3784e+00 17.4829 1.5441 1.4988 -2.93
2 3.8388e+00 16.4669 1.5005 1.4673 -2.21
3 1.6185e+00 15.6789 1.4622 1.4408 -1.46
4 6.5171e-01 15.764 1.4331 1.4231 -0.70
5 2.7261e-01 14.9935 1.4095 1.4102 0.05
6 1.0535e-01 15.4667 1.3953 1.4007 0.39
7 3.8212e-02 16.014 1.3828 1.3997 1.22
8 1.3067e-02 17.3512 1.3783 1.4025 1.76
9 3.9695e-03 19.2511 1.377 1.4073 2.20
10 1.0991e-03 22.068 1.3815 1.4203 2.81
11 2.6483e-04 25.8205 1.389 1.4337 3.22
12 5.1499e-05 30.4573 1.4061 1.4516 3.24
13 8.2305e-06 37.7877 1.4269 1.4699 3.01
14 1.1920e-06 58.2323 1.463 1.498 2.39
Average 23.1% 42.5% 43.7% 0.9%
Table 42 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 5.9423e+00 16.3059 1.8143 1.7541 -3.32
2 2.4098e+00 15.1148 1.7696 1.729 -2.29
3 9.4782e-01 14.659 1.7451 1.723 -1.27
4 3.4801e-01 14.9126 1.7292 1.7242 -0.29
5 1.2369e-01 15.9119 1.7232 1.7332 0.58
6 3.9807e-02 17.6115 1.7259 1.7536 1.60
7 1.1696e-02 20.0832 1.7474 1.7894 2.40
8 2.8706e-03 23.1154 1.7786 1.8343 3.13
9 5.7736e-04 27.0941 1.823 1.8988 4.16
10 8.7540e-05 33.0822 1.902 1.9783 4.01
11 9.2235e-06 42.8557 2.0079 2.0999 4.58
12 5.9441e-07 60.5582 2.2366 2.3194 3.70
Average 25.1% 83.3% 86.1% 1.4%
Table 43 


5.2 Gluon channel

figure cdf-bin1gg.png
Figure 51 
figure cdf-bin2gg.png
Figure 52 
figure cdf-bin3gg.png
Figure 53 
figure cdf-bin4gg.png
Figure 54 
figure cdf-bin5gg.png
Figure 55 


5.2.1 Ratio gluon channel

figure cdf-bin1gg-ratio.png figure cdf-bin2gg-ratio.png

figure cdf-bin3gg-ratio.png figure cdf-bin4gg-ratio.png

figure cdf-bin5gg-ratio.png
Figure 56 


5.2.2 K-Factors gluon channel

gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.2332e+01 18.3447 1.1842 1.2089 2.09 1.1569 1.2089 4.49
2 5.8392e+00 16.3363 1.1805 1.1919 0.97 1.1439 1.1919 4.20
3 2.5648e+00 15.1286 1.1815 1.1771 -0.37 1.1301 1.1771 4.16
4 1.1293e+00 14.1836 1.1586 1.1679 0.80 1.1205 1.1679 4.23
5 4.9055e-01 13.6802 1.1719 1.1587 -1.13 1.1155 1.1587 3.87
6 2.1819e-01 13.5437 1.1882 1.1527 -2.99 1.1124 1.1527 3.62
7 8.8655e-02 13.4586 1.1679 1.1489 -1.63 1.1074 1.1489 3.75
8 3.4626e-02 13.8317 1.1696 1.148 -1.85 1.1115 1.148 3.28
9 1.3375e-02 14.4361 1.1688 1.1453 -2.01 1.1085 1.1453 3.32
10 5.0470e-03 15.5616 1.1852 1.1504 -2.94 1.1185 1.1504 2.85
11 1.7391e-03 16.953 1.1856 1.1543 -2.64 1.1279 1.1543 2.34
12 5.7740e-04 18.58 1.1889 1.166 -1.93 1.1357 1.166 2.67
13 1.7438e-04 20.4884 1.2169 1.1773 -3.25 1.1554 1.1773 1.90
14 4.6164e-05 23.1129 1.2243 1.1985 -2.11 1.1727 1.1985 2.20
15 1.2831e-05 27.0039 1.2479 1.2243 -1.89 1.2038 1.2243 1.70
16 2.4676e-06 36.4214 1.2859 1.2655 -1.59 1.2588 1.2655 0.53
17 2.1933e-07 58.6463 1.3422 1.3305 -0.87 1.3374 1.3305 -0.52
Average 20.28% 20.3% 18.6% -1.4% 15.4% 18.6% 2.8%
Table 44 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.1773e+01 17.3309 1.1882 1.2291 3.44 1.1767 1.2291 4.45
2 5.3141e+00 15.7537 1.1818 1.2111 2.48 1.161 1.2111 4.32
3 2.3850e+00 14.375 1.18 1.1974 1.47 1.1478 1.1974 4.32
4 1.0304e+00 13.4666 1.1811 1.1861 0.42 1.1371 1.1861 4.31
5 4.5067e-01 12.9087 1.1752 1.1733 -0.16 1.1276 1.1733 4.05
6 1.9389e-01 12.6869 1.1704 1.1693 -0.09 1.1247 1.1693 3.97
7 8.0186e-02 12.7669 1.1643 1.1627 -0.14 1.1203 1.1627 3.78
8 3.1674e-02 13.1506 1.177 1.1608 -1.38 1.1213 1.1608 3.52
9 1.1795e-02 14.0111 1.1735 1.1591 -1.23 1.1202 1.1591 3.47
10 4.3733e-03 15.1797 1.1781 1.1627 -1.31 1.1276 1.1627 3.11
11 1.5238e-03 16.7691 1.1924 1.1665 -2.17 1.1321 1.1665 3.04
12 4.7637e-04 18.7902 1.1939 1.1767 -1.44 1.1439 1.1767 2.87
13 1.4064e-04 21.2221 1.2045 1.1898 -1.22 1.164 1.1898 2.22
14 3.6648e-05 24.4097 1.2254 1.2092 -1.32 1.187 1.2092 1.87
15 7.2081e-06 28.8382 1.2483 1.2386 -0.78 1.2265 1.2386 0.99
16 1.1827e-06 36.0876 1.2804 1.2838 0.27 1.2738 1.2838 0.79
17 9.3577e-08 53.4882 1.3445 1.3473 0.21 1.3545 1.3473 -0.53
Average 20.1% 20.4% 20.1% -0.2% 16.7% 20.1% 2.9%
Table 45 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.0490e+01 17.5576 1.1918 1.308 9.75 1.2514 1.308 4.52
2 4.7944e+00 16.2211 1.1866 1.2863 8.40 1.2302 1.2863 4.56
3 2.1471e+00 14.8956 1.1863 1.2656 6.68 1.2091 1.2656 4.67
4 9.1016e-01 14.2023 1.1731 1.2457 6.19 1.1906 1.2457 4.63
5 3.8312e-01 13.8172 1.1749 1.2356 5.17 1.1795 1.2356 4.76
6 1.6165e-01 13.8845 1.185 1.2254 3.41 1.1698 1.2254 4.75
7 6.4513e-02 14.1844 1.1743 1.2187 3.78 1.1642 1.2187 4.68
8 2.3995e-02 14.8484 1.1752 1.2118 3.11 1.1564 1.2118 4.79
9 8.5956e-03 15.8953 1.1928 1.2121 1.62 1.1561 1.2121 4.84
10 2.9408e-03 17.3788 1.1894 1.2161 2.24 1.1641 1.2161 4.47
11 9.2721e-04 19.3332 1.2042 1.2221 1.49 1.1706 1.2221 4.40
12 2.4773e-04 22.1375 1.211 1.2373 2.17 1.1894 1.2373 4.03
13 6.0900e-05 26.0269 1.2306 1.2529 1.81 1.2116 1.2529 3.41
14 1.1095e-05 31.8232 1.2662 1.2838 1.39 1.2579 1.2838 2.06
15 1.5785e-06 40.2833 1.2995 1.3305 2.39 1.3149 1.3305 1.19
16 2.3408e-07 57.7304 1.3417 1.3985 4.23 1.3902 1.3985 0.60
Average 21.9% 21.1% 25.9% 3.9% 21.3% 25.9% 3.9%
Table 46 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 9.3784e+00 17.4829 1.1948 1.4397 20.50 1.3791 1.4397 4.39
2 3.8388e+00 16.4669 1.1745 1.4086 19.93 1.3458 1.4086 4.67
3 1.6185e+00 15.6789 1.1808 1.3816 17.01 1.3162 1.3816 4.97
4 6.5171e-01 15.764 1.1735 1.3624 16.10 1.293 1.3624 5.37
5 2.7261e-01 14.9935 1.18 1.3457 14.04 1.2759 1.3457 5.47
6 1.0535e-01 15.4667 1.1844 1.3325 12.50 1.2643 1.3325 5.39
7 3.8212e-02 16.014 1.1864 1.3278 11.92 1.2543 1.3278 5.86
8 1.3067e-02 17.3512 1.188 1.3254 11.57 1.2507 1.3254 5.97
9 3.9695e-03 19.2511 1.2008 1.3257 10.40 1.2544 1.3257 5.68
10 1.0991e-03 22.068 1.2123 1.3346 10.09 1.263 1.3346 5.67
11 2.6483e-04 25.8205 1.2328 1.3472 9.28 1.2774 1.3472 5.46
12 5.1499e-05 30.4573 1.2529 1.372 9.51 1.317 1.372 4.18
13 8.2305e-06 37.7877 1.2743 1.4069 10.41 1.3684 1.4069 2.81
14 1.1920e-06 58.2323 1.3041 1.4916 14.38 1.4652 1.4916 1.80
Average 23.1% 21.0% 37.2% 13.4% 30.9% 37.2% 4.8%
Table 47 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 5.9423e+00 16.3059 1.1994 1.6725 39.44 1.6053 1.6725 4.19
2 2.4098e+00 15.1148 1.1845 1.6347 38.01 1.5606 1.6347 4.75
3 9.4782e-01 14.659 1.1936 1.6136 35.19 1.5306 1.6136 5.42
4 3.4801e-01 14.9126 1.1938 1.5986 33.91 1.5103 1.5986 5.85
5 1.2369e-01 15.9119 1.1909 1.589 33.43 1.4929 1.589 6.44
6 3.9807e-02 17.6115 1.2015 1.587 32.08 1.4921 1.587 6.36
7 1.1696e-02 20.0832 1.2017 1.5956 32.78 1.4887 1.5956 7.18
8 2.8706e-03 23.1154 1.2069 1.6111 33.49 1.5118 1.6111 6.57
9 5.7736e-04 27.0941 1.2306 1.6507 34.14 1.5464 1.6507 6.74
10 8.7540e-05 33.0822 1.2463 1.7251 38.42 1.6413 1.7251 5.11
11 9.2235e-06 42.8557 1.259 1.9175 52.30 1.832 1.9175 4.67
12 5.9441e-07 60.5582 1.1491 1.4305 24.49 1.2008 1.4305 19.13
Average 25.1% 20.5% 63.5% 35.6% 53.4% 63.5% 6.9%
Table 48 


6 D0 jets

6.1 All channels

figure d0con-bin1.png
Figure 57 
figure d0con-bin2.png
Figure 58 
figure d0con-bin3.png
Figure 59 
figure d0con-bin4.png
Figure 60 
figure d0con-bin5.png
Figure 61 
figure d0con-bin6.png
Figure 62 


6.1.1 Ratio all channels

figure d0con-bin1-ratio.png figure d0con-bin2-ratio.png

figure d0con-bin3-ratio.png figure d0con-bin4-ratio.png

figure d0con-bin5-ratio.png figure d0con-bin6-ratio.png
Figure 63 


6.1.2 K-Factors full prediction

K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 2.3282e+04 11.2934 1.1952 1.2695 6.22
2 8.8665e+03 10.2301 1.1629 1.2361 6.29
3 3.7927e+03 9.7392 1.1386 1.2129 6.53
4 1.7678e+03 9.41 1.122 1.1947 6.48
5 8.9746e+02 9.2724 1.1082 1.1794 6.42
6 4.8546e+02 9.0215 1.0985 1.1682 6.35
7 2.7591e+02 8.9452 1.0912 1.1603 6.33
8 1.5967e+02 8.8119 1.084 1.1531 6.37
9 8.6959e+01 8.8544 1.077 1.1462 6.43
10 4.3619e+01 8.8333 1.072 1.1393 6.28
11 2.1406e+01 8.9002 1.0673 1.1334 6.19
12 9.8640e+00 9.0221 1.063 1.1294 6.25
13 4.7402e+00 9.192 1.0578 1.1244 6.30
14 2.4291e+00 9.3741 1.0572 1.1227 6.20
15 1.1835e+00 9.6935 1.0581 1.1222 6.06
16 5.1120e-01 10.1172 1.0579 1.1202 5.89
17 2.1106e-01 10.7344 1.0596 1.1217 5.86
18 8.2381e-02 11.5402 1.0608 1.123 5.86
19 2.9294e-02 12.8752 1.0682 1.1276 5.56
20 9.9894e-03 15.0811 1.0726 1.1291 5.27
21 3.0638e-03 19.2471 1.0822 1.1346 4.84
22 5.9961e-04 31.0056 1.0902 1.1371 4.30
23 9.0820e-05 45.5599 1.1163 1.1471 2.76
Average 12.9% 9% 15.3% 5.9%
Table 49 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 2.1728e+04 11.47 1.2381 1.3129 6.04
2 8.1627e+03 10.5165 1.2027 1.2775 6.22
3 3.4953e+03 10.061 1.1769 1.2532 6.48
4 1.6199e+03 9.826 1.158 1.2345 6.61
5 8.0500e+02 9.7325 1.1434 1.2177 6.50
6 4.3791e+02 9.526 1.1291 1.2038 6.62
7 2.4307e+02 9.5132 1.1226 1.1956 6.50
8 1.4182e+02 9.4416 1.1161 1.1899 6.61
9 7.6800e+01 9.4736 1.1093 1.1839 6.72
10 3.8278e+01 9.5848 1.1034 1.1768 6.65
11 1.8237e+01 9.6905 1.0965 1.1689 6.60
12 8.1536e+00 9.9031 1.0912 1.1661 6.86
13 3.7998e+00 10.1606 1.0912 1.1646 6.73
14 1.8641e+00 10.4222 1.0871 1.1618 6.87
15 8.7747e-01 10.8379 1.0905 1.1646 6.80
16 3.5585e-01 11.4567 1.0892 1.1633 6.80
17 1.3900e-01 12.3298 1.0915 1.165 6.73
18 5.3148e-02 13.4911 1.097 1.168 6.47
19 1.5559e-02 15.4698 1.1005 1.1705 6.36
20 3.7822e-03 19.2421 1.1123 1.1738 5.53
21 7.4934e-04 28.0381 1.1225 1.1794 5.07
22 6.1715e-05 46.9948 1.1516 1.188 3.16
Average 13.5% 12.3% 19.5% 6.3%
Table 50 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.7739e+04 12.0673 1.3253 1.3983 5.51
2 6.6481e+03 11.369 1.2828 1.3602 6.03
3 2.8083e+03 11.1644 1.2535 1.3343 6.45
4 1.2952e+03 11.1887 1.2322 1.3125 6.52
5 6.6021e+02 10.2182 1.214 1.2969 6.83
6 3.4070e+02 10.2663 1.2042 1.288 6.96
7 1.7052e+02 10.111 1.1924 1.2771 7.10
8 7.5323e+01 10.2419 1.1858 1.2703 7.13
9 3.6419e+01 10.2693 1.1776 1.2654 7.46
10 1.8092e+01 10.5054 1.1719 1.259 7.43
11 8.5257e+00 10.7795 1.1693 1.2596 7.72
12 3.6738e+00 11.229 1.1677 1.2594 7.85
13 1.6477e+00 11.7495 1.1686 1.2605 7.86
14 7.6533e-01 12.3378 1.1726 1.2638 7.78
15 3.5918e-01 13.1141 1.1743 1.2677 7.95
16 1.4486e-01 14.1806 1.1817 1.2714 7.59
17 4.1615e-02 16.025 1.1909 1.2778 7.30
18 1.0516e-02 18.9392 1.2023 1.2857 6.94
19 2.4549e-03 24.0553 1.2214 1.2957 6.08
20 1.6393e-04 34.0392 1.2551 1.3069 4.13
Average 13.7% 20.7% 29.1 6.9%
Table 51 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.5249e+04 13.2561 1.4585 1.533 5.11
2 5.2668e+03 12.6595 1.4147 1.4948 5.66
3 2.1975e+03 12.5006 1.3838 1.4696 6.20
4 9.6320e+02 11.5469 1.3601 1.4506 6.65
5 4.6424e+02 11.3927 1.3419 1.4379 7.15
6 2.3508e+02 11.4617 1.3334 1.43 7.24
7 1.1078e+02 11.6263 1.3291 1.4301 7.60
8 4.5867e+01 11.9463 1.323 1.4267 7.84
9 1.9989e+01 12.0667 1.3216 1.4325 8.39
10 9.2228e+00 12.4861 1.3291 1.4387 8.25
11 3.7713e+00 13.0025 1.3237 1.4436 9.06
12 1.2448e+00 14.6819 1.3455 1.4614 8.61
13 3.5744e-01 15.9733 1.365 1.4825 8.61
14 1.0992e-01 17.9723 1.3861 1.5047 8.56
15 2.9682e-02 20.5192 1.4137 1.5253 7.89
16 7.2732e-03 24.2715 1.4462 1.5529 7.38
17 3.9206e-04 32.6071 1.5167 1.5978 5.35
Average 15.3% 37.6% 47.7% 7.4%
Table 52 


K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 1.1684e+04 13.2001 1.6682 1.7364 4.09
2 4.0542e+03 12.7548 1.6202 1.707 5.36
3 1.5651e+03 12.432 1.5971 1.6906 5.85
4 6.6951e+02 12.5395 1.5795 1.6881 6.88
5 2.9506e+02 12.6582 1.575 1.6903 7.32
6 1.3622e+02 12.9305 1.5801 1.6993 7.54
7 5.6908e+01 13.3802 1.585 1.7141 8.15
8 2.0321e+01 14.1627 1.6071 1.7432 8.47
9 6.3418e+00 15.2376 1.6403 1.7849 8.82
10 1.9329e+00 16.6521 1.6782 1.8345 9.31
11 6.8901e-01 18.3248 1.7199 1.8823 9.44
12 2.2119e-01 20.585 1.7843 1.9438 8.94
13 4.5679e-02 24.6268 1.8646 2.0251 8.61
14 6.7894e-03 31.7718 1.9903 2.1428 7.66
15 4.0224e-04 44.9061 2.1932 2.3337 6.41
Average 18.4% 71.2% 84.1% 7.5%
Table 53 
K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) NLO NLO %
1 7.2148e+03 14.7391 1.9951 2.0597 3.24
2 2.2811e+03 14.7294 1.9756 2.0648 4.52
3 7.4168e+02 14.8434 1.9779 2.089 5.62
4 2.7132e+02 15.442 1.994 2.1367 7.16
5 9.9553e+01 16.0892 2.0465 2.1895 6.99
6 3.8789e+01 16.9895 2.0925 2.2613 8.07
7 1.4726e+01 18.0928 2.1424 2.3356 9.02
8 5.7305e+00 19.3456 2.2393 2.4322 8.61
9 1.8183e+00 21.2101 2.3425 2.5497 8.85
10 3.8345e-01 24.4537 2.5143 2.7387 8.92
11 8.1686e-02 28.3113 2.7345 2.9693 8.59
12 1.0941e-02 35.1504 3.0933 3.3383 7.92
13 3.6139e-04 52.8355 4.1342 4.3045 4.12
Average 22.5% 2.4% 2.6% 7%
Table 54 


6.2 Gluon channel

figure d0con-bin1gg.png
Figure 64 
figure d0con-bin2gg.png
Figure 65 
figure d0con-bin3gg.png
Figure 66 
figure d0con-bin4gg.png
Figure 67 
figure d0con-bin5gg.png
Figure 68 
figure d0con-bin6gg.png
Figure 69 


6.2.1 Ratio gluon channel

figure d0con-bin1gg-ratio.png figure d0con-bin2gg-ratio.png

figure d0con-bin3gg-ratio.png figure d0con-bin4gg-ratio.png

figure d0con-bin5gg-ratio.png figure d0con-bin6gg-ratio.png
Figure 70 


6.2.2 K-Factors gluon channel

gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 2.3282e+04 11.2934 1.1922 1.2223 2.52 1.1709 1.2223 4.39
2 8.8665e+03 10.2301 1.1835 1.2008 1.46 1.1499 1.2008 4.43
3 3.7927e+03 9.7392 1.1769 1.1858 0.76 1.1366 1.1858 4.33
4 1.7678e+03 9.41 1.1867 1.1751 -0.98 1.1283 1.1751 4.15
5 8.9746e+02 9.2724 1.1765 1.1663 -0.87 1.1209 1.1663 4.05
6 4.8546e+02 9.0215 1.1694 1.1603 -0.78 1.118 1.1603 3.78
7 2.7591e+02 8.9452 1.1649 1.1581 -0.58 1.1164 1.1581 3.74
8 1.5967e+02 8.8119 1.1811 1.1544 -2.26 1.1138 1.1544 3.65
9 8.6959e+01 8.8544 1.1769 1.1529 -2.04 1.1135 1.1529 3.54
10 4.3619e+01 8.8333 1.1732 1.1497 -2.00 1.1126 1.1497 3.33
11 2.1406e+01 8.9002 1.162 1.1499 -1.04 1.1151 1.1499 3.12
12 9.8640e+00 9.0221 1.1743 1.1513 -1.96 1.1138 1.1513 3.37
13 4.7402e+00 9.192 1.1808 1.1524 -2.41 1.1176 1.1524 3.11
14 2.4291e+00 9.3741 1.1825 1.1555 -2.28 1.1228 1.1555 2.91
15 1.1835e+00 9.6935 1.1832 1.161 -1.88 1.133 1.161 2.47
16 5.1120e-01 10.1172 1.1955 1.1667 -2.41 1.1399 1.1667 2.35
17 2.1106e-01 10.7344 1.1904 1.1772 -1.11 1.1536 1.1772 2.05
18 8.2381e-02 11.5402 1.2108 1.1908 -1.65 1.167 1.1908 2.04
19 2.9294e-02 12.8752 1.2178 1.2101 -0.63 1.1908 1.2101 1.62
20 9.9894e-03 15.0811 1.2423 1.2305 -0.95 1.2148 1.2305 1.29
21 3.0638e-03 19.2471 1.2626 1.2598 -0.22 1.2491 1.2598 0.86
22 5.9961e-04 31.0056 1.2957 1.2935 -0.17 1.2905 1.2935 0.23
23 9.0820e-05 45.5599 1.3339 1.3499 1.20 1.3532 1.3499 -0.24
Average 12.9% 20.1% 19% -0.9% 15.8% 19% 2.8%
Table 55 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 2.1728e+04 11.47 1.1893 1.2639 6.27 1.2097 1.2639 4.48
2 8.1627e+03 10.5165 1.1796 1.2379 4.94 1.1857 1.2379 4.40
3 3.4953e+03 10.061 1.1852 1.2216 3.07 1.1693 1.2216 4.47
4 1.6199e+03 9.826 1.1805 1.2085 2.37 1.1571 1.2085 4.44
5 8.0500e+02 9.7325 1.1707 1.1968 2.23 1.1472 1.1968 4.32
6 4.3791e+02 9.526 1.1688 1.1876 1.61 1.141 1.1876 4.08
7 2.4307e+02 9.5132 1.1705 1.1831 1.08 1.1368 1.1831 4.07
8 1.4182e+02 9.4416 1.1838 1.1812 -0.22 1.1356 1.1812 4.02
9 7.6800e+01 9.4736 1.185 1.1781 -0.58 1.1311 1.1781 4.16
10 3.8278e+01 9.5848 1.1688 1.1749 0.52 1.1274 1.1749 4.21
11 1.8237e+01 9.6905 1.1803 1.1711 -0.78 1.1299 1.1711 3.65
12 8.1536e+00 9.9031 1.1959 1.1731 -1.91 1.1335 1.1731 3.49
13 3.7998e+00 10.1606 1.1779 1.1756 -0.20 1.1333 1.1756 3.73
14 1.8641e+00 10.4222 1.1909 1.1779 -1.09 1.1395 1.1779 3.37
15 8.7747e-01 10.8379 1.1958 1.1864 -0.79 1.1428 1.1864 3.82
16 3.5585e-01 11.4567 1.1953 1.1931 -0.18 1.1557 1.1931 3.24
17 1.3900e-01 12.3298 1.2031 1.2028 -0.02 1.169 1.2028 2.89
18 5.3148e-02 13.4911 1.2334 1.2191 -1.16 1.1874 1.2191 2.67
19 1.5559e-02 15.4698 1.2426 1.2365 -0.49 1.2067 1.2365 2.47
20 3.7822e-03 19.2421 1.2659 1.2614 -0.36 1.2462 1.2614 1.22
21 7.4934e-04 28.0381 1.2838 1.2993 1.21 1.2852 1.2993 1.10
22 6.1715e-05 46.9948 1.3418 1.3509 0.68 1.3478 1.3509 0.23
Average 13.5% 20.4% 21.3% 0.74% 17.4% 21.3% 3.4%
Table 56 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.7739e+04 12.0673 1.188 1.3436 13.10 1.2873 1.3436 4.37
2 6.6481e+03 11.369 1.198 1.3133 9.62 1.256 1.3133 4.56
3 2.8083e+03 11.1644 1.1829 1.2915 9.18 1.2328 1.2915 4.76
4 1.2952e+03 11.1887 1.1656 1.2741 9.31 1.2158 1.2741 4.80
5 6.6021e+02 10.2182 1.1784 1.26 6.92 1.2008 1.26 4.93
6 3.4070e+02 10.2663 1.1861 1.2537 5.70 1.1963 1.2537 4.80
7 1.7052e+02 10.111 1.1803 1.244 5.40 1.1864 1.244 4.86
8 7.5323e+01 10.2419 1.1874 1.2387 4.32 1.1796 1.2387 5.01
9 3.6419e+01 10.2693 1.1763 1.2342 4.92 1.1732 1.2342 5.20
10 1.8092e+01 10.5054 1.1751 1.2296 4.64 1.1729 1.2296 4.83
11 8.5257e+00 10.7795 1.1833 1.2312 4.05 1.1703 1.2312 5.20
12 3.6738e+00 11.229 1.2057 1.2332 2.28 1.1763 1.2332 4.84
13 1.6477e+00 11.7495 1.2011 1.2365 2.95 1.1837 1.2365 4.46
14 7.6533e-01 12.3378 1.2072 1.2427 2.94 1.1883 1.2427 4.58
15 3.5918e-01 13.1141 1.2198 1.2517 2.62 1.1981 1.2517 4.47
16 1.4486e-01 14.1806 1.2162 1.2605 3.64 1.216 1.2605 3.66
17 4.1615e-02 16.025 1.2417 1.2793 3.03 1.2257 1.2793 4.37
18 1.0516e-02 18.9392 1.2682 1.3022 2.68 1.2729 1.3022 2.30
19 2.4549e-03 24.0553 1.2867 1.3393 4.09 1.3242 1.3393 1.14
20 1.6393e-04 34.0392 1.3245 1.3893 4.89 1.3804 1.3893 0.64
Average 13.7% 20.9% 27.2% 5.3% 22.2% 27.2% 4.2%
Table 57 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.5249e+04 13.2561 1.1923 1.4726 23.51 1.4114 1.4726 4.34
2 5.2668e+03 12.6595 1.1838 1.4355 21.26 1.3718 1.4355 4.64
3 2.1975e+03 12.5006 1.1882 1.4087 18.56 1.3407 1.4087 5.07
4 9.6320e+02 11.5469 1.1926 1.3883 16.41 1.3191 1.3883 5.25
5 4.6424e+02 11.3927 1.1795 1.3728 16.39 1.299 1.3728 5.68
6 2.3508e+02 11.4617 1.1722 1.3617 16.17 1.2904 1.3617 5.53
7 1.1078e+02 11.6263 1.1891 1.3568 14.10 1.2848 1.3568 5.60
8 4.5867e+01 11.9463 1.18 1.3485 14.28 1.274 1.3485 5.85
9 1.9989e+01 12.0667 1.1913 1.3506 13.37 1.2714 1.3506 6.23
10 9.2228e+00 12.4861 1.1974 1.3529 12.99 1.2775 1.3529 5.90
11 3.7713e+00 13.0025 1.1846 1.3524 14.17 1.2758 1.3524 6.00
12 1.2448e+00 14.6819 1.2096 1.3665 12.97 1.2928 1.3665 5.70
13 3.5744e-01 15.9733 1.203 1.3826 14.93 1.3065 1.3826 5.82
14 1.0992e-01 17.9723 1.2341 1.4011 13.53 1.342 1.4011 4.40
15 2.9682e-02 20.5192 1.2357 1.4297 15.70 1.3731 1.4297 4.12
16 7.2732e-03 24.2715 1.2644 1.4718 16.40 1.4296 1.4718 2.95
17 3.9206e-04 32.6071 1.307 1.5641 19.67 1.5451 1.5641 1.23
Average 15.3% 20.6% 40% 16.1% 33.6% 40.1% 4.9%
Table 58 


gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 1.1684e+04 13.2001 1.1967 1.6629 38.96 1.6007 1.6629 3.89
2 4.0542e+03 12.7548 1.1875 1.6233 36.70 1.5502 1.6233 4.72
3 1.5651e+03 12.432 1.2011 1.5954 32.83 1.5135 1.5954 5.41
4 6.6951e+02 12.5395 1.1844 1.5807 33.46 1.4936 1.5807 5.83
5 2.9506e+02 12.6582 1.1809 1.5703 32.97 1.4813 1.5703 6.01
6 1.3622e+02 12.9305 1.2123 1.5655 29.13 1.4714 1.5655 6.40
7 5.6908e+01 13.3802 1.1986 1.5665 30.69 1.4713 1.5665 6.47
8 2.0321e+01 14.1627 1.2159 1.5769 29.69 1.4742 1.5769 6.97
9 6.3418e+00 15.2376 1.2074 1.5934 31.97 1.4867 1.5934 7.18
10 1.9329e+00 16.6521 1.2138 1.6201 33.47 1.5083 1.6201 7.41
11 6.8901e-01 18.3248 1.239 1.6514 33.28 1.5426 1.6514 7.05
12 2.2119e-01 20.585 1.2254 1.7028 38.96 1.59 1.7028 7.09
13 4.5679e-02 24.6268 1.2369 1.7912 44.81 1.7293 1.7912 3.58
14 6.7894e-03 31.7718 1.1985 2.075 73.13 2.0602 2.075 0.72
15 4.0224e-04 44.9061 1.1371 1.4991 31.84 1.2847 1.4991 16.69
Average 18.4% 20.2% 64.5% 36.8% 55.1% 64.5% 6.4%
Table 59 
gg K-Factor gg K-Factor, NNLO
bin (%) Exact Thr NLO NLO %
1 7.2148e+03 14.7391 1.2004 1.9522 62.63 1.8857 1.9522 3.53
2 2.2811e+03 14.7294 1.196 1.9255 60.99 1.8391 1.9255 4.70
3 7.4168e+02 14.8434 1.1859 1.9162 61.58 1.8166 1.9162 5.48
4 2.7132e+02 15.442 1.2224 1.9309 57.96 1.8063 1.9309 6.90
5 9.9553e+01 16.0892 1.2034 1.9457 61.68 1.8335 1.9457 6.12
6 3.8789e+01 16.9895 1.1997 1.9761 64.72 1.853 1.9761 6.64
7 1.4726e+01 18.0928 1.222 2.011 64.57 1.8989 2.011 5.90
8 5.7305e+00 19.3456 1.208 2.0719 71.51 1.9374 2.0719 6.94
9 1.8183e+00 21.2101 1.2115 2.1508 77.53 2.0074 2.1508 7.14
10 3.8345e-01 24.4537 1.1939 2.352 97.00 2.2418 2.352 4.92
11 8.1686e-02 28.3113 1.0476 3.0379 189.99 2.9002 3.0379 4.75
12 1.0941e-02 35.1504 1.2291 1.5741 28.07 1.3978 1.5741 12.61
13 3.6139e-04 52.8355 1.4345 0.2947 -79.46 0.279 0.2947 5.63
Average 22.5% 21.2% 93.4% 62.9% 82.3% 93.4% 6.3%
Table 60